Email the author | Follow on Twitter
on September 19, 2016 at 2:10 PM, updated September 19, 2016 at 3:09 PM
Opponents of Pennsylvania’s 40 percent tax on e-cigarettes are rallying around new legislation that would repeal what vape store owners describe as the death knell of the industry.
Lawmakers and Gov. Tom Wolf avoided another protracted budget impasse this year by relying on new revenues from an expansion of gambling, reforms to the liquor system and higher taxes on smokers and the businesses that cater to their nicotine habits. That includes a 40 percent tax on the wholesale price on vaping supplies as well as a 40 percent “floor tax” on the inventory currently sitting on vape shop shelves.
The “floor tax,” in particular, was seen as an insurmountable obstacle to for an industry dominated by sole proprietor operations and small businesses that can’t afford to make lump sum payments to the state.
“It’s more profitable to throw out brand new, never-used product than to keep it on the shelves,” said Chris Hughes, a vape shop owner and a leading voice of opposition to the law. “That’s really bad.”
Unless the law can be repealed, Hughes said he plans to close his Fat Cat Vapor Shop in Montoursville prior to the Oct. 1 effective date of the tax. In the meantime, he’s selling off inventory at steep discounts and plans to discard whatever’s left.
A pair of proposals are working their way through the state House and Senate that would eliminate the “floor tax” and replace the 40 percent tax with a tax on vaping liquid at 5 cents per milliliter. Someone who bought a 15 mL vile of liquid, for example, would pay 75 cents for the vape tax in addition to a standard 6 percent sales tax.
“If these small businesses do decide to close and lay off workers, not only will the new vape tax revenues fall short of estimates, but the state may lose significant sales and income tax revenues,” one of the 5-cent-per-mL bills’ sponsors, Rep. Jeff Wheeland, said in his co-sponsorship memo. The Lycoming County Republican did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
Pennsylvania had expected to receive $13.3 million from the 40-percent e-cigarette tax, although vape shop owners said the real-world revenue would be much lower as smokers turned to online retailers and the shops shut their doors.
It remains unclear how much revenue the 5-cents-per-mL tax would generate.
Hughes said he opposes any tax on vape supplies — since they are used by some smokers to wean themselves off cigarettes — but believes the new bills would keep shops like his open. Supporters of the revised tax, including Hughes, have planned a rally next Monday in the Capitol Rotunda.
Wheeland’s bill, which was referred to the House Finance Committee on Monday, garnered several dozen co-sponsors from both parties. House Majority Leader Dave Reed, R-Indiana County, has expressed his general support for a per-mL tax.
Last week, Hughes took his efforts a step further by announcing a write-in challenge to his own lawmaker, incumbent Republican state Rep. Garth Everett. Grover Norquist, an anti-tax political advocate, spoke at an event at Fat Cat Vapor Shop.
Everett, like many of his Republican colleagues, voted for the state spending bill and also voted for the revenue package.
“We don’t get to pick and choose on a menu,” Everett said. “It’s a ‘yes’ or ‘no’ on the whole package. I already voted for the spending package, so I felt obligated to vote for the revenue package. Some of my colleagues didn’t and I don’t understand that — to vote to spend money without the revenue.”
Everett, who represents parts of Lycoming and Union counties, said he would have changed a number of things about the budget if that was an option.
“I’m not a fan of voting for any tax increases,” he said, “but I thought this was as good a deal as we were going to get.”
Hughes, for his part, said he’s pledged not to raise any taxes, particularly the kinds of taxes included in this year’s budget bill that target low-income people. On the issue of a natural gas severance tax, for example, he hasn’t arrived at a firm position although he generally supports gas drilling. He’s also “satisfied” with current abortion laws, pro-gay marriage and a supporter of gun rights.
“I want to win,” he said, of his candidacy. “I recognize the challenges of a write-in campaign, but I think the district size is manageable and I have a lot of friends and volunteers who are willing to help.”
Everett said he’s willing to consider any change to the vape tax that’s revenue-neutral, but he doesn’t believe Wheeland’s proposal fits that bill.
“It’s not as easy as it stands with a 5-cents-per-mL tax,” he said. “The tax would need to be almost 22 or 25 cents to raise the same revenue that we did with the budget package.”
A lobbyist for the Smoke Free Alternatives Trade Association said he estimated the proceeds from the per-mL tax at closer to $14 million, based on current sales.
Everett also doesn’t believe as many shops will close as the owners have said. Those that do close, he said, likely were on that trajectory already.
“It’s the natural way with anything new,” Everett said. “An entrepreneurial opportunity comes out, a lot of people rush in, the ones with some good business plans survive and it weeds itself out.”